Showing posts with label Science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Science. Show all posts

Friday, 5 October 2012

Epistemology

Mill- Went beyond his predecessors by claiming that not only all science, but also all of mathematics is derived from experience. The axioms of geometry and the basic principles of mathematics are all founded on sensory experience. Mill sees the fact that the sum of equals is always an equal as an inductive truth, or a law of nature.

Newman- Belonged to the same empiricist tradition as Mill and disliked the German metaphysics, he described it as “a vain system of words without ideas”. Newman stated that the only direct acquaintance we have with things outside of ourselves is through our senses, so to think we could have “direct knowledge” of immaterial things is just ludicrous. Even our senses don’t allow us to be far out from ourselves e.g. we need to be near things to touch them. We cannot think or act without accepting that some truths aren’t intuitive and are not clearly demonstrated, yet they are still sovereign.
The difference between knowledge and certainty:
Knowledge= if I know “p” then “p” is true.
Certainty= I’m certain of “p” but “p” may still be false.
To be certain of something is to believe that it is true. Anyone who loses certainty off a statement was never really certain of it.

C.S. Pierce- Tried to create an epistemology appropriate for an age of scientific enquiry. Pierce observes that inquiry always originates in doubt and ends in relief, the only object of enquiry is to settle opinion.
4 methods commonly used:
- Tenacity
- Authority
- A priori method
- Scientific method
It is possible for “p” to be true even if every person on earth believes “p” is false.
Belief has 3 properties:
1. Something we are aware of
2. Appeases the irritation of doubt
3. Establishes a habit

Frege- Believed epistemology had been given a place in philosophy when it really should have been assigned to logic. A proposition may be thought of without being true, and a proposition may be true without being thought of. Frege created a doctrine of 2 separate worlds, one interior and private, and the other exterior and public. Physical things in the public world are accessible to all of us , but then there is also the private inner world of sense impressions and ideas. Frege also argued that there must also be a “third realm”, the realm of objective thought.

Russell- What is immediately known in sensation is different from any real object. Sense data are the only things we can be really certain of. What we immediately experience is an inference from what is immediately known. There is no proof that life isn’t just a dream but that doesn’t mean that it’s wrong. Knowledge of what is known by acquaintance is the only way we can have knowledge of things we have never experienced. E.g. how we have knowledge of “Europe” even though it’s too big to be comprehended by the senses.

Wittgenstein – Private language argument- there is no way of identifying terms of consciousness without referring to the public world. Doubt needs ground, genuine doubt will result in a change of someone’s behaviour. In order to express doubt that “p” one must understand what is meant by saying “p”.

Sunday, 30 September 2012

Science and Certainty

So, we’re back in the warm and cosy arms of Winchester University, having somehow survived the workload, feeling brave and ready to face the pressure of second year. It just got serious. We’re now working on WINOL…well not quite yet, but we know what our roles are and it won’t be long before we take off our training wheels and try our hand at being serious journalists.

What better way to kick start the second year than with a healthy dose of HCJ? You can’t deny it, everyone has been missing their weekly confusion of philosophy. So, here it goes…

Science and Certainty
Science is the search for truth.
Kant would argue that the universe is ultimately unknowable. Kant and many other modern theoretical physicists hold the view that the cosmos (the universe as a whole) is more like a computer game where the objects, landscape, space and time are created in consciousness and then fade away again. First into the distance where you can still see them, and then they disappear completely. The objects in themselves “noumena” are still there and are unchanging, it is our perception of the objects “phenomena” which changes. What you are looking at will alter depending on your point of view. A simple example of this is the fact that things look smaller when they are far away but, as the majority of people acknowledge, the object has in fact not changed size. Schopenhauer agreed with Kant in the sense that he noted the difference between noumena and phenomena. However Schopenhauer believed there was only one universal noumena: the “will of the universe” as a thing in itself.

From Kant Schopenhauer and Nietzsche we inherit the idea that existence is not a predicate of any possible objects as nothing “causes” existence. Existence is a necessary precondition of our perception and consciousness. This is regarded as one of the big breakthroughs of the scientific revolution but it remained submerged during the 19th century by the empiricists, derived from Aristotle. It wasn’t until the 20th century when Einstein’s revolution in physics awakened the West from the ideas of Aristotle, and Newton’s “clockwork universe” (universal laws of causation, Newton believed the world was ordered and knowable).  Einstein’s theory of relativity lead to an increase in doubt and uncertainty in what were regarded as the most reliable principles of scientific experimentation.  There was an explosion in technological innovation as people were beginning to work on the basis that we know virtually nothing, but humanity has the ability to strive to know more.  
Logic – Deduction VS Induction
Deduction :
All swans are white
This is a swan
Therefore it is white


If your axiom (all swans are white) is wrong then your argument will fail. This is an example of a flawed deductive argument as in fact not all swans are white, there are black swans too. An example of an axiomatic truth is “cogito ergo sum” I think therefore I am.
Newton’s law of motion describes motion as being from one point to another, but then this raises the question, can there be any motion if there are infinite distances? Newton was regarded as objective fact for over 200 years. The laws of motion were seen as true independent of perception, and were said to be read off nature like a mirror.   

In Einstein’s theory of relativity he abandons the idea that the universe has a time. Time is a mental phenomena and is a part of our perception. According to Einstein’s experiments there are different types of time and this has been confirmed by space travel. For example, time elapses at different rates not only in different theoretical points in the universe (such as black holes), but also in empirically observable points such as at the top of a tall building or during space travel. This means that astronauts are hours younger than they should be because time is going slower.
In Wittgenstein’s “The Tractatus” he stated the “world consists of facts”, there is no objective truth only language games. Even logic itself is regarded as a language game. The Verification Principle argues that the truth of any proposition is the way in which you verify it. If a proposition cannot be verified then it is neither true nor false it is merely vocalisation, like the quacking of a duck. However Karl Popper later constructed the argument that the Verification Principle itself cannot be verified therefore the core of the principle is flawed. The Falsification Principle goes on to argue that something isn’t true unless it can be both verified and falsified.